OUR BLOG

A deferred judgment and sentence allows a first-time offender in Colorado to plead guilty, complete a period of court supervision, and then have the guilty plea withdrawn and the charge dismissed permanently. For someone facing their first criminal charge, this is often the best available outcome.

At the Law Office of Jacob Martinez, our Denver criminal defense team has negotiated deferred judgment agreements in Colorado courts since 2014.

How a Deferred Judgment and Sentence Works in Colorado

The defendant enters a guilty plea, and the court delays entering a conviction and imposing a sentence for a set period. For felonies, that period can last up to four years. For misdemeanors and petty offenses, the maximum is two years.

During the deferral, the court places the defendant under supervision with conditions similar to probation. If the defendant complies with every condition without violating any, the guilty plea is withdrawn, and the case is permanently dismissed, meaning it cannot be refiled.

Who Qualifies for a Deferred Judgment in Colorado

Deferred judgments are generally reserved for first-time offenders facing non-violent charges, though eligibility depends on the district attorney’s willingness to agree and the judge’s approval. The types of charges where deferred judgments are most commonly negotiated include:

• Drug possession and related controlled substance offenses
• Theft, including shoplifting and other property offenses
• Criminal mischief and trespass
• Certain assault charges without domestic violence enhancements
• Fraud, forgery, and financial crime charges
• Some DUI cases, in limited circumstances, though most prosecutors are reluctant

Certain sex offenses are excluded entirely. Our Denver criminal defense attorney evaluates each client’s charge, history, and the local DA’s policies before advising whether a deferred judgment is realistic.

What Conditions Come With a Deferred Sentence

Conditions are similar to probation and typically include:

• Regular check-ins with a probation officer
• Community service hours or charitable donations
• Full restitution payments to victims
• Drug and alcohol treatment or mental health counseling
• Random drug and alcohol testing
• A prohibition on new arrests or violations of any law

Domestic violence cases carry mandatory additional conditions, including a treatment program and a protection order. The agreement, signed by all parties, spells out every requirement in detail, and our criminal defense attorney reviews each condition to ensure the terms are achievable before the client signs.

What Happens If You Violate the Terms

A violation can trigger a hearing where the prosecution asks the court to enter the conviction and impose the original sentence. The standard of proof at the hearing is lower than at trial, so the prosecution need not prove the violation beyond a reasonable doubt.

If the court finds a violation, it can sentence the defendant as if the deferral had never existed, and the defendant cannot choose to go to trial because that right was waived when the guilty plea was entered.

However, for drug-related violations, the court has an important option. If the judge finds that imposing the conviction would not serve the goals of the law and that public safety would not be at risk, the court can continue the deferred judgment and add stricter conditions instead of revoking it. The court can extend the deferral by up to two years or impose up to 90 days in county jail while keeping the deferred judgment intact.

How a Deferred Judgment Affects Your Criminal Record

Upon successful completion, the guilty plea is withdrawn, and the charge is dismissed permanently, so no conviction appears on the record. However, the arrest and dismissed charge may still appear on background checks unless the record is sealed.

Colorado law allows defendants who complete a deferred judgment to petition to seal the criminal record, which removes the case from public databases for employment, housing, and professional licensing purposes. The record-sealing petition process is straightforward once the deferred judgment is complete. Our Colorado criminal defense attorney advises every client who completes a deferred judgment to pursue sealing as soon as they are eligible.

Talk to Our Denver Team About Whether a Deferred Judgment Fits Your Case

A deferred judgment is not automatic and not available in every case, but when it is available, it can mean the difference between a permanent conviction and a clean record. The Law Office of Jacob E. Martinez has defended Colorado criminal cases since 2014, and Jacob E. Martinez has been recognized as a Top 100 Trial Lawyer by The National Trial Lawyers. Contact us online to discuss your case with our Denver criminal defense lawyer.